"Misslyckad Philip Roth-film."
Michael Tapper,
Sydsvenskan
"Stel amerikansk mardröm."
Jens Peterson,
Aftonbladet
"Ewan McGregor kavlar i sin debutfilm ut Philip Roths 400 sidor tjocka roman ”American pastoral” till en räcka vackra men platta Edward Hopper-tablåer."
Jan Söderqvist,
SvD
"...missing the wit, nuance, and insight of a book thought by many – correctly, maybe – to be unadaptable."
John Nugent,
Empire